Kristina Derby ConsultingContact
Office Operations

Answer every call: what a 24/7 answering service really costs

4 min read

Resource for psychologists and mental health professionals

A new client who reaches voicemail often calls the next name on the list. Here is what it costs to make sure a real person picks up, day or night.

The short answer: for most solo and small practices, a live, HIPAA-ready answering service costs about $150 to $400 a month. That is often less than what one weekly client brings in. A full-time front-desk employee costs about $4,600 to $5,400 a month.

Why it matters

People often reach out to a therapist at night or on weekends, and only after a lot of thought. When they get voicemail, many hang up and try someone else. Insurance navigators work the same way: they go down a list and book the first therapist who answers and has an opening. You can't pick up while you're in session. An answering service can.

What the big services charge

PATLive

  • Starting plans: $49 a month plus $2.99 a minute. Or $99 for 50 minutes, $189 for 100 minutes.
  • Good to know: 24/7 included. No night or weekend fees.

AnswerConnect

  • Starting plans: About $145 to $365 a month for 100 to 400 minutes.
  • Good to know: HIPAA mode is a setting you turn on. Call recording turns off when it's on.

Ruby

  • Starting plans: $250 for 50 minutes, $395 for 100 minutes.
  • Good to know: The most polished, and the priciest per minute. HIPAA option available.

Specialty Answering Service

  • Starting plans: From about $44 a month plus per-minute charges.
  • Good to know: Has a plan built for mental health practices. 14-day free trial.

Prices checked November 2026 and change often. Confirm on each company's site. KDC is not paid by any of these companies.

Quick math: 40 calls a month at about 2.5 minutes each is 100 minutes. That runs about $190 to $400 a month. One client who books weekly sessions at $150 brings in about $600 a month.

The trade-offs

The good

  • A real person answers every time, including nights, weekends, holidays and during sessions.
  • They can book a free consult or take a clear message, so the caller doesn't move on.
  • Medical answering services will sign a BAA, so they are covered under HIPAA.
  • Far cheaper than hiring front-desk staff.

The watch-outs

  • Most charge by the minute. Going over your plan costs about $1.65 to $5 a minute.
  • They follow a script. They can't answer clinical questions.
  • You still need to call people back fast.
  • Quality varies. Test the service by calling it yourself.

Before you sign up

  1. Get a signed BAA (Business Associate Agreement) before the first call. If they won't sign one, pick another service.
  2. Write a crisis script. Anyone in danger is told to call 988 (the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline) or 911, and you decide who, if anyone, gets paged after hours.
  3. Keep messages short. Name, phone number, best time to call and a few words on why. No clinical details.
  4. Pick a plan with room to spare so a busy month doesn't bring big overage charges.
  5. Call it yourself at 9 PM on a Sunday and see how it sounds.

What about AI answering?

AI phone answering is cheaper. HIPAA-ready AI plans for therapists often run about $99 to $149 a month. But AI should never try to handle someone in crisis, and many callers to a therapist need a warm human voice. For now, a live person is the safer choice for mental health practices. AI can still help with simple jobs like reminders and scheduling.

Not sure which one fits your practice?

Tell us a little about your practice and how calls come in today. We'll look at the options with you and help you think it through.

Start a conversation


Sources: PATLive pricing · AnswerConnect healthcare · Ruby pricing (Carly) · Specialty Answering Service · Goodcall private practice comparison · NextPhone comparison · Central cost guide · Layer3 Labs therapy cost guide

Need help implementing this for your business?

Start a Conversation